I'm not sure how many of you out there are familiar with the work of
Daniel Quinn, but it is some very thought provoking and insightful reading. I highly recommend his work. His writing is quite critical of the status quo or "civilization" which he contrasts with tribalism. In
Beyond Civilization he comes to better explanation of what tribalism really is and how it can be applied in our modern world.
See, he believes that a tribe is simply a group of people making a living together. His examples in the book to flesh out the concept are traveling circuses and a small newspaper that he, his spouse, and some friends worked on together. One of the hallmarks is that while people have specialties, they also pitch in for the good of the group and work to maintain it. I think this idea has merit and you could apply it to a number of other professions. My father was a firefighter so I saw this way of life very closely and I have to say it applies.
Another tribal profession is police or law enforcement and I would like to examine it through this lens.
As we can see from Quinn's definition, the police are indeed engaged in making a living together. And with examples I will cite, they will go to great lengths to preserve the good of the tribe. Most of the time when a group does this, it is a good thing. But with a tribe whose mission statement is to "serve and protect" when the good of the tribe and the mission statement are at odds, the tribe usually comes first. This is a problem for those of us not wearing the shield.
In fact, I assert that this very dynamic is what assures institutional corruption within police departments.
Lying to protect other tribe members is a common example and illustrative of the Law and morality being subverted for the tribes ends. Here's some examples:
- Salinas, California: Police said two officers shot a man to death
who acted erratically and attempted to stab officers. But, one witness
said that the man was already on the ground and stunned from a Taser
when police shot him at least four times. Police, on the other hand,
said the officers felt like their lives were in danger. ow.ly/wO95I
- Update: Dona Ana, New Mexico (First reported 04-17-14): The sheriff’s
deputy who was driving 114 mph when she hit and killed a pedestrian will
not be charged with vehicular homicide. An official said proof to
support that charge is not present in this case. She will be prosecuted
for lesser included offenses. ow.ly/wuJWv
- Clearwater, Florida: Three police officers face suspension after an
incident involving what appears to have been a drunken colleague getting
a special treatment. Internal Affairs investigators found a fellow
officer was allowed to go home without so much as a field sobriety test
even though he appeared to be drunk. ow.ly/wpnKx
- " The worst misconduct for the month of April is the story of the five
Chicago police officers who each took the witness stand to testify about
how evidence was obtained in connection with a drug case. Each officer
got up on the witness stand and told the same story, but not one of them
was telling the truth.
Video evidence offered by the defense contradicted the coordinated
falsehood that the police agents offered up. This practice (called
“testilying” by some) is a serious flaw in the U.S. justice system.
Every now and then, like here, the veil is pulled back—this time thanks
to video evidence. Was this the very first time that these officers
committed perjury? How many cases like this are out there?"
- Above found at PoliceMisconduct.net
Excessive force for the sake of "officer safety", this often endangers the presumed innocent(remember that, eh?), and the general public. Examples:
- Miami, Florida: A total of 23 officers fired a total of at least 377
rounds at 2 unarmed men, killing them both. Bullets were sprayed
everywhere. They hit cars, fence posts and neighboring businesses and
blasted holes in a townhouse where a 12-year-old dove to the ground for
cover and a four month old slept in his crib. ow.ly/wFz1v
- Round Rock, Texas: A men was sitting in his car, charging his phone,
when 6 police officers tried to arrest him, according to court
documents. The man now is a quadriplegic after the officers’ “extremely
aggressive use of force,” one of his lawyers said. ow.ly/wDjfh
- Above from PoliceMisconduct.net
- This Reason.tv video should make your blood boil. Elements of excessive force and lies to save their own hides.
There are tons of examples. If your blood pressure isn't high enough, read a newspaper or go to
CopBlock for an arterial stress test.
I believe that understanding that law enforcement agencies and police departments are tribes will go a long way toward helping us frame the problem of institutional corruption. When seen for what this is, it becomes clear that as long as law enforcement is a profession performed by a group there will be corruption and injustice at the expensive of those outside the tribe.